Melaka Review: Why It Wasn’t My Favorite City

A Melaka review can sound quite different depending on which of us is writing it. Ian saw a city full of potential. I spent more time watching my step on broken sidewalks and wondering why so many old buildings were being left to deteriorate. Melaka, also known as Malacca, had places I enjoyed, especially beside the river. It simply never became my favorite stop in Malaysia.

We arrived from Singapore after a drive of a little more than three hours. I had been looking forward to the landscape, hoping to see some forest and more of the enormous trees I had admired in Singapore. From the road, much of what I saw was oil palm and rubber plantations, with occasional strips of trees beside the highway. It was green, certainly, just not the kind of green I had imagined. That disappointment was mine, and it arrived before we had even reached the city.

Walking in Melaka: Close Together, Not Always Easy

The historic center was compact enough for us to explore on foot. Short distances did not always make for comfortable walking. Heavy rain greeted our arrival, which I welcomed for the temporary relief from the heat. While it passed, we had time to plan our stay and soon realized that many of the places we wanted to see were close together.

What surprised me was how much traffic we encountered around the visitor areas, including Jonker Walk outside its market closures. I had pictured more space to wander without having to keep checking for vehicles. Some sidewalks also demanded more attention than the buildings above them: missing drain covers, loose concrete slabs and signs blocking the way could send us back onto the road. In a few places, the smell from the drains was difficult to ignore. Walking became an exercise in looking up for the architecture and down for the next step.

The Waterfront That Left Me Cold

The stretch of waterfront we explored did little to persuade me to linger by the sea. On our way toward a gold-domed mosque, we passed construction sites and rows of closed ground-floor premises. Whole stretches appeared almost empty. We were told that the area was being developed into a future visitor hub, with businesses taking space ahead of that promised growth. I could not verify the commercial plans; what I could see was a district with very little life at street level.

Along the shore, rocks formed a hard edge to the land, and the water looked dirty to me. This was not somewhere I wanted to settle down for an afternoon by the sea. The most absorbing part was a small muddy area we watched from a bridge: fish moving across the mud, fiddler crabs disappearing into their holes and birds going about their business. Litter lay nearby, and we saw work clearing mangroves and leveling ground. Watching that little pocket of wildlife alongside the building activity was more upsetting than the unfinished shops. I wondered how much room would remain for it.

Old Buildings I Wanted to See Saved

The neglected old buildings bothered me because they were among the things that made Melaka interesting. We passed empty properties showing signs of deterioration close to the historic sights. At the same time, there was plenty of new construction. I kept wondering what some of those older buildings could become with care, repair and a reason for people to use them again. Their condition was part of what we encountered on that trip, not a survey of the city’s conservation work today.

Melaka’s heritage importance is real. Its historic center forms part of the UNESCO World Heritage property shared with George Town, inscribed in 2008. That recognition concerns particular historic areas, not every street or new development across the city. For me, it made the contrast between buildings worth preserving and the attention given to new projects harder to overlook.

Quiet Nights Were Hard to Find

Our nights were less peaceful than I had expected. For the first few nights, loud cars and motorbikes woke me repeatedly. I cannot turn that into a verdict on every hotel or neighborhood in Melaka; it was what happened where we were staying. It did make the description of the city as a quiet escape difficult for me to recognize.

The customized cars were hard to miss, with spoilers, alloy wheels, stickers and accessories extending to the fuel doors and wheel hardware. Some owners had clearly put a great deal of thought into the details. I would have appreciated a little less enthusiasm for the soundtrack after bedtime. If traffic noise bothers you too, ask your accommodation about the room’s position before booking. A central address tells you very little about how well you will sleep.

My Melaka Review: What I Would Go Back For

The river was my favorite part of Melaka. Our walks there were calmer, and the old buildings gave us plenty to look at without the same frustration I had along the seafront. Those walks are why I would not tell someone to skip the city simply because it did not suit me. There were places I was pleased to have seen, even when the stay as a whole did not win me over.

For a first visit focused on the central sights, I would allow one or two days. That is my suggested starting point, with more time if you want to explore the food or museums slowly. Our guide to what to do in Melaka covers the sightseeing side, while our Melaka food guide takes the trip in another direction. I would arrive with an interest in the city’s history and realistic expectations about urban walking. The river and the heritage buildings earned their place in my memories. The traffic and the waterfront did too, for different reasons.

Practical Context for Visiting Melaka Today

The old account should not be read as saying that Melaka has no pedestrian areas today. Official notices document car-free arrangements in Banda Hilir, and Tourism Melaka lists Jonker Walk’s market on Friday, Saturday and Sunday evenings. Check current local notices for the roads and dates involved. Neither that market nor a traffic closure makes the entire city pedestrian-only.

Frequently Asked Questions

Sources and Further Reading

You Might Also Like

• Ian’s view of Melaka and its potential
• What to do in Melaka
• Food in Melaka: What We Tried
• Kristang Cuisine and Kristang Legacy